Kara no Kyoukai #3: Tsuukaku Zanryuu (Remaining Sense of Pain)

One of the things I love about Nasu’s writing is the unflinching examination of the darker aspects of the human condition: I don’t think you can avoid the grim details and keep the power of the subject matter intact when you’re telling a story like this. There’s rape, mutiliation and all sorts of nastiness to be found here – I’m not sure if it would make it to these shores in any form without the BBFC’s Editing Scissors having their fun with it first but whatever. I found this to be in turns gleefully out-there and decidedly uncomfortable viewing but the said nastiness is very much relevant and in context.

kara-no-kyoukai-3-1

It also looks spectacular: ufotable are doing a wonderful job of recreating Nasu’s vision and Takeuchi’s iconic characters. The rumours I’ve read about how they were consulted more than they were for either of the TV adaptations of Tsukihime and Fate/Stay Night seem to be right on the money: it has the visceral, borderline-sadistic but ultimately exhilerating atmosphere of their visual novels that neither TV outing fully captured. At the same time it has a tangible quality; a feeling that’s akin to the ‘synesthaesia’ that Gaguri and IKnight noted in Mononoke and Gankutsuou. Oh yeah, it has another Kajiura-penned music score that ups the ante from previous outings too.

Tsukihime, the visual novel: overview

The original Tsukihime VN is another case where I saw the adaptation before the source material which is something I normally try to avoid. On the plus side it’s the arrangement that leaves you more bemused at first, but less disappointed at the end in that disjointed or poorly-explained plot points and insufficiently-developed characters are set out in their entirety, with a wonderful feeling of seeing things fall into place with supernatural grace. It’s like watching God play Tetris or something.

an-arcueid-good-end

I recently dug out and rewatched my old copy of the first disc of the Lunar Legend Tsukihime TV show and although I now know all its background and hence its failings, on reflection it’s still not a complete loss. I hope the There Is No Tsukihime Anime joke is old news now but should anyone feel the need to dig up that old fossil I do offer the choice of whether you want me to use the knife or needles on you, at no extra charge. There IS a Tsukihime anime but it’s a very different, and less well-fed, beast. The creature of the night that spawned it however comes highly recommended.

Kara no Kyoukai: Satsuiji Kohatsu (part 1)

The more I watch of this series the more I fall in love with the way it’s all put together. I daresay the sedate pacing and idiosyncratic dialogue won’t be to everyone’s taste but personally I’m finding myself more and more in my element; “Where were you all my life?” springs to mind. Thanks for answering my “Where’s the love?” question so well though, guys. ^_^ It’s reassuring to know that these films are getting more attention than I initially thought.

kara-no-kyoukai-2-3

Like its predecessor Kara no Kyoukai: Satsujin Kohatsu expects patience and open-mindedness from the viewer but in return I was rewarded with a viewing experience that is more mature than either of the other Nasu/Takeuchi animated adaptations; I was once again left speechless at the marriage of visuals and music but the storytelling goes further into the characters’ heads, and is all the more satisfying for that. There are plenty of supernatural thrillers around these days but it’s not often that it’s handled in this way: namely portraying events from the point of view of the supposed killer as well as those caught up in the investigations that ensue.

Kara no Kyoukai #1: Fukan Fuukei (Overlooking View)

I can’t believe this hasn’t whipped up a frenzied cult following, unless I’ve been dense enough to miss it. Anything with a connection to Type-Moon seems to be given a fair hearing in these parts so seriously, where’s the love, guys? I guess it’s down to a sparse release schedule that may prevent an international fanbase gaining momentum like TV shows do, or the fact that the full series of films is still incomplete so isn’t yet ready for Western licences. In any case it’s hidden under my radar for two long.

kara-no-kyoukai-1-4-resized

I’ve actually been working back through the Type-Moon stuff in reverse order: anime adaptations before VNs, and sampling the later VN before the earlier one. Taking a step back though I’m seeing an evolution of the recurring themes and character types, noticing Kinoko Nasu’s and Takashi Takeuchi’s trademark flourishes respectively. Back when I first reviewed Tsukihime I thought there was nothing really amiss with it apart from the pacing and obvious gaps in character backgrounds but what that, and everything from these guys that I’ve seen so far, had by way of compensation were atmospherics and underpinning concepts. Kara no Kyoukai floored me straight away on these two things alone.

Heaven’s Feel and Fate/Stay Night retrospection make me write a long post again

I made it. The final route of Fate/Stay Night in its brutal, beautiful, painful, compelling entirety. The whole run of Heaven’s Feel after the divergence point is an experience similar to the time I watched the Nausicaä movie then read the manga through to the end, which is really saying something coming from me. The quality and sheer scope of the storytelling meant that I felt an even greater attachment to the characters; if ‘equivalent exchange’ is a recurring theme in the F/S N franchise the same idea applies to the emotional (not to mention time) investment you put into it, which in my case turned out to be one hell of a lot.

sakura-in-the-kitchen
She’ll make a man of him yet

Heaven’s Feel was immensely rewarding for me but was the darkest instalment of the visual novel as a whole. That said, even the most disconcerting moments were relevant to the plot and were important in drawing attention to the plight of the central character. Sakura always stayed in the background in the earlier routes, serving little purpose other than to cook meals and blush a lot but this route is the point where she has chance to shine; it really shook up everything I thought I knew up to that point about some of the supporting cast too.

Fate/Stay Night’s Unlimited Blade Works route: an inconvenient ideal

The first route of F/S N was the main inspiration for the TV series but what’s unlocked at its completion, Unlimited Blade Works, isn’t represented much there so came as a pleasant surprise to me. It goes off in a different direction that’s just as interesting in its own way and expands on themes that were merely touched on before, making some clever parallels between characters and bringing in a startling variant on the underlying fate vs free will theme. Additionally, rather than making Ilya and Berserker the main antagonists it’s Caster and her master who drive the events along this time around.

and so he prays...
Epic foreshadowing? You betcha

Shirou’s relationship with Saber is played down to give his screentime with Rin room to breathe but at the same time there’s the all-important explanation of Archer’s origins that gave this route its true impact and makes the story focus on Shirou’s fight more than Saber’s. It goes without saying that what’s coming up is as spoilerific as hell so don’t say I didn’t warn you.

“Twilight fades through blistered Avalon…” Fate/Stay Night’s Fate route

My blogging kohai has a lot to answer for. With one full story thread of the Fate/Stay Night visual novel under my belt I can see where he’s coming from in terms of the connections that hold everything together, although it’s taken a fair while in getting there. Since I’m not a gamer the idea of spending hours and hours on something like this is pretty alien to me but as I said in my warm-up post the interactive nature of the VN works wonders in bringing the story to life in a way that the TV version couldn’t (although my not being sloshed this time around must have helped). It’s only part of the full picture of course: there are two other routes to follow afterwards but this one concentrates on the Shirou/Saber relationship in particular.

fate-working-together
“..into the uncertain divine/we scream into the last divide…”

I wasn’t as fascinated by Saber in the TV show but when the events are geared towards portraying events from her and Shirou’s point of view I had a much clearer picture of her circumstances and personality so felt for her predicament much more keenly. While Rin is the tsundere character (not a bad thing I might add!), Saber is I think someone even more interesting, with a imaginatively-realised backstory that I can’t help but admire on so many levels.