White Album end: a question of lust (and spineless losers)

As I commented in Kabitzin’s excellent retrospective I found this show a bit of a chore to sit through at first but burning through the last five episodes in the space of an afternoon was better than the weekly episode viewing I initially tried. I quite like the open ending with its promise of more to come later in the year but also felt a twinge of guilt: the show is not without its flaws but I feel that it was given a bit of an unfair beating. More than anything I want to be annoyed at the series for the right reasons and want to understand why it took the approaches it did.

rina-yuki-and-yayoi

Can I be bothered to dig up the eroge adaptation issue again? Quite frankly I can’t see the point. The idea of branching narratives and periodic storyline choices in a VN -> indecisive protagonist in a strictly linear plotline of a TV series ought to be obvious by now, or at least I hope so. This isn’t the area where the show falls down – rather, the frustration viewers felt was the price of presenting the characters in the light they were; not so much the question of whether the faults lie in a poor adaptation or the act of recreating the original material complete with those faults.

White Album first impressions: the little things that go unsaid

White Album was pretty much the first of the new season’s shows to be subbed which is part of the reason why I think it caused such a ruckus: the first over the parapet drawing most of the fire and all that. Admittedly it’s an unusual series that has a style you’ll either love or hate, so I’m not overly surprised that reviews have been mixed. I waited a while before sampling the first three or so episodes for myself though because while one post is an honest opinion, a whole slew of them on a bloated feedreader makes for an offputting wave of negativity. Of course, when something divides opinion at all it has to be doing something right, y’know?

Realistic fiction FTW
Star-crossed lovers in more ways than one

I’m not going quite as far as 21stDigitalBoy’s wonderful gasp of nonstop Directorgasm but the guy has a point. So too does Michael over at Low on Hit Points in praising its restraint and subtlety. The old argument of “what’s so special about normal people doing normal things?” rears its head again because it’s another slice of life effort; anime bloggers can never seem to agree to disagree on that issue so for this show I’m hoping we’ll be able to fail to understand one another in peace this time. Granted, White Album does take a little while to slip into its groove and there are one or two unfortunate elements resulting from its visual novel origins (cue epic sigh of exasperation at that old chestnut too) but the fact that it has that subtlety, restraint and maturity is why I’m so (cautiously) optimistic for it.